Recently, Grimes Pools was in the thick of their busy season. Builds were in every stage, some still in permitting, others halfway done, and they barely had time to look up. Then their renewal hit: another premium increase with no heads-up and no strategy to reduce it.
Fortunately, they reevaluated their needs with a new carrier who stepped in with a clear plan: a full review of their program, a benchmark against industry peers, and a roadmap for how to move forward. Going with a pool-specific program, resulted in about 15 percent savings, and risk management improvements like driver safety protocols and subcontractor agreements. Today, they have direction, better protection, and the confidence to focus on growing their business.
So why are companies like Grimes Pools seeing their rates spike? And more important, how do you stay afloat? Let’s dive into the four forces pushing premiums higher, the pitfalls to watch when you shop for coverage, and the practical steps that can soften the blow at renewal time.
The Four Currents Lifting Pool Insurance Premiums
1. Claims and litigation are swelling.
Slip-and-falls around wet decks, chemical handling injuries, construction defect suits—every claim costs more than it did five years ago. Industry-wide, liability payouts have surged, climbing an average of 16% annually, with no slowdown in sight. Juries are also handing out larger awards (the so-called “social inflation” effect), so carriers pad rates to keep loss ratios healthy.
2. Mother nature packs a bigger punch.
Hurricane Idalia caused an estimated $2.5 to $4 billion in insured losses, with total economic damage potentially reaching $20 to $30 billion. Add to that a record-breaking year for hail in Texas—affecting over 2 million homes—and extensive wildfire losses in California, and reinsurers (the companies that insure your insurer) are facing mounting costs. As reinsurance expenses climb, primary carriers pass that burden downstream, contributing to higher premiums for policyholders.
3. Materials and labor costs keep climbing.
Materials and labor costs continue to rise due to persistent workforce shortages and price increases for essential construction materials. Additionally, uncertainty around tariffs on imported steel and aluminum could push these expenses even higher. Repairing the same claim simply costs more, and underwriters factor these increased costs directly into your premium.
4. Shrinking carrier appetite.
Fewer insurers are willing to write pool and spa risks—especially in high-claim states or for builders with even a minor loss history. Carriers are trimming their books, limiting coverage, or exiting the space altogether. Less competition means less pricing pressure, and underwriters get pickier about who they’ll take on. That combination drives premiums up and narrows your options.
Choosing an Insurance Carrier: Look Past the Sticker Price
Seek industry-specific coverage.
A one-size-fits-all contractor policy often excludes the unique risks faced by pool professionals—like chemical handling or pollution losses and design defects. Be sure your policy specifically addresses these exposures to avoid costly gaps in coverage.
Scrutinize the fine print.
Look for sublimits that quietly gut your protection—water damage caps, mold exclusions, or subcontractor warranty clauses.
Gauge financial strength.
Choose an A-rated carrier with a proven track record in the construction space. A carrier experienced in this sector is more likely to offer stable pricing and coverage that accounts for the unique risks pool professionals face. They’re also less likely to pull capacity when the market tightens. Check AM Best or Standard & Poor’s ratings before you sign.
Test the claims process.
Insurance is only as good as the adjuster who shows up when something breaks. Talk to peers: Did the carrier assign a dedicated construction specialist? How fast were reserves set? Was the settlement fair? Just as important, make sure the broker you work with has a dedicated claims team to assist and advocate for you throughout the process.
Demand proactive risk support.
The best partners help you avoid claims in the first place—onsite safety audits, toolbox talk templates, chemical handling checklists, contract language reviews. Those services can trim losses and, in turn, tame future rate hikes.
Planning Ahead: Five Moves to Keep Costs Contained.
- Budget for reality, not hope.
Build an eight to ten percent line-item increase into next year’s P&L. If you beat it—great. If not, you’re covered. - Document your safety culture.
Underwriters love evidence: signed training logs, SDS binders, weekly job‑site inspections. Hard data can earn credits worth three to five points on your rate. - Review limits and endorsements annually.
Did you add commercial pool remodeling? Start subbing out more work? Growth shifts your risk profile; adjust coverage before the insurer does it for you. - Benchmark against peers.
Ask your broker for a blind comparison of deductibles, limits, and rates across similar pool companies in your region. Gaps—high or low—signal where to tweak. - Lock in multi-year programs when you can.
Some carriers offer two or three-year rate agreements for accounts with solid loss histories. It’s hedge insurance against the next hard market wave.
Where Choosing a Quality Insurance Carrier Fits In
If you’d rather spend your time pouring concrete than decoding exclusions, a specialized partner helps. Look for carriers focused on pool and spa risks, from backyard installations to Olympic-size complexes. A solid pool insurance program closes industry-specific gaps, advocates during claims, and delivers risk management tools that keep premiums from spiraling.
The Takeaway
Premiums are rising because claims cost more, storms hit harder, and the global reinsurance tide is pushing all boats higher. Yet pool pros aren’t powerless. Understand the market forces, pick a carrier that truly knows chlorinators from coping stones, and put a proactive plan in place long before renewal. Do that, and you’ll keep insurance from eating the profits you worked so hard to build—no matter how choppy the water gets.
The post Insurance Premiums on the Rise: How Pool Pros Can Stay Afloat appeared first on PoolMagazine.com – Get The Latest Pool News.
